AGDInteractive - Sierra Adventure Game Remakes Forum

Who had the most fun games?

Mario and Sonic for me. Crash....gets a thumbs down.

I vote Mario, because there are so many different kinds of Mario games, that variation is pretty much guaranteed.

Sonic's not half bad (hence the reason for me owning Sonic Mega Collection for GC), but Mario wins. I want more (good) spin-off games before Sonic has a possibility of taking the lead.

Crash - no thanks. I've tried some of the games, but I don't really like them much.

Mario and Sonic. Crash stinks.

Sonic, but that's because I used to play those game books. All four of them.

Mario is the BEST! Crash sucks and Sonic is


"Mamma Mia!"

Being a Nintendo fan I should say Mario. But Sonic is far more supiorior (and less annoying)

Let's see, we have:

A goofy-looking bandicoot, vs.

A hedgehog that can run really fast vs.

An Italian plumber from Brooklyn who can fly, ride dinosaurs, and shoot fireballs.

...And this is a contest because why? Mario all the way!

~Wolfgang

Sonic, of course. Just one of many other classics by Sega

"Classics"? Alex Kidd, anyone?

My vote goes to Mario, of course.

Crash Bandicoot, my absolute favorite platform game. For nostalgic value I would have to havce said Mario, Super Mario 3 on the NES is still a major classic and awesome game (especially on the PC with an emulator so you can save between worlds... ) I was never into Sonic too much.

I voted for Sonic

The Mario and Sonic games were about the same (Sonic was slightly better, but with less variety). Crash was fun, but was far below the other two in quality.

The cartoons were my deciding point, and the Sonic X cartoon was REALLY well done, and the rest did not mess up much at all. The Mario cartoons were HORRIBLE

For some strange reason I've always preferred the sidekicks to the hero. Like my favourite character in Mario is Luigi. For Sonic, it's Tails, etc.

Mario's had the best games. Sonic comes in at a very close second, but his 3D adventures kind of fall apart when compared to Mario's 3D adventures. Plus, Mario's been in two excellent RPGs, to boot! I never played Crash's stuff, so I won't comment. Sonic does have the best story behind his character, though--this can be proven with the Sonic comic...

In a fight, though, Sonic would rip Mario apart and send his remains flying back to Brooklyn, decapitating Crash in the process. WINNER.

this can be proven with the Sonic comic...

Comics are NOT canon. If they were, Super Sonic would be EVIL and Sonic could become Polar Sonic.

I voted for Sonic

The Crash games were horrible, and the Mario and Sonic games were about the same (Sonic was slightly better, but with less variety)

The cartoons were my deciding point, and the Sonic X cartoon was REALLY well done, and the rest did not mess up much at all. The Mario cartoons were HORRIBLE

O_o You're voting based on cartoons?!
I don't belive how you could place Mario and Sonic on....Crash's level. Either you don't like platformers or you voted "I've lost my marbles" in my other poll/

No Link?!?!

O_o You're voting based on cartoons?!
I don't belive how you could place Mario and Sonic on....Crash's level. Either you don't like platformers or you voted "I've lost my marbles" in my other poll/

I didn't place Crash on Mario and Sonic's level.

I placed them on each other's level, I thought that Mario and Sonic were equals, with Crash WAAAAAYYYYYYY down. I voted based on the cartoons because that was the only way I could find a winner.

Sorry, the way you put it, it sounded like you thought all three series were the same.

Comics are NOT canon. If they were, Super Sonic would be EVIL and Sonic could become Polar Sonic.

I never said they were canon. Out of those three characters, though, Sonic's the only one to have a decent, long-running comic that actually does provide a rich story for the character.

And Polar Sonic and evil Super Sonic? Where'd you get those from...

I chose Mario partly because of the different ways to say "Mama Mia!" in Mario VS. DK! I also like Sonic too! I don't care for Crash though. Although the sight of Angel Bandicoot(and my fav, Puffy Bandicoot) is funny, it happens WAY too often!

Also, Mario DID have a decent, in fact GREAT comic in Nintendo Power!(though it was not as good as Link's)

Sir Nyrhinen wrote:Mario is the BEST! Crash sucks and Sonic is


"Mamma Mia!"

Sonic is an angry smiley?

Mario belongs to the mob, Crash has rabies and Sonic's on methamphetamines.

*Twirls finger around head*

Teeheehee, you're cute, Jafar.

Judging by my own name, I don't think there's any need for an explanation as to who I voted for...