Future Remake: Part Deux
Moderators: adeyke, VampD3, eriqchang, Angelus3K
-
- Knight Status
- Posts: 276
- Joined: Sun Mar 31, 2002 12:35 am
- Contact:
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
I'm going to go with KQ8, only because I think you would have more fun remaking that game than any other on the list. You would really have to stretch your creative muscles to pull that one off. It would require a dramatically reworked story, all new puzzles... I'd be really interested to see what you'd come up with.
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
Oh I hope you all decide to do one last final remake.... and if you do, please let it be KQ4. It would be great to finish off the AGDI storyline... especially considering KQ3Redux ends practically screaming "To Be Continued...."
-
- Honorary AGD
- Posts: 5378
- Joined: Fri Sep 13, 2002 1:19 am
- Location: US of A
- Contact:
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
We couldn't just tie a pretty bow on everything, could we? What would be the fun in that? 

Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
Camelot, Laura Bow, or Mask of Eternity would be good. I purposely didn't vote for KQ4 even though it's the logical choice. Camelot would be my #1 choice. And Mask of Eternity #2. I vote Laura Bow just because I'd like to see more Sierra mystery games.
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
1. King's Quest IV
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
2. Conquests of Camelot
3. Quest for Glory V
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
2. Conquests of Camelot
3. Quest for Glory V
- GwydionGR
- Peasant Status
- Posts: 15
- Joined: Mon Feb 21, 2011 10:28 am
- Location: Alexandroupolis, GREECE
- Contact:
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
OK, I think I may raise some eyebrows here, but here's my 2 cents.
Whats the point in re-making adventures of the , hmm, "second Sierra on-line Era" ? I'm reffering to the adventures such as Kings Quest 4, Space Quest 3, Police Quest 2, Codename:Iceman, Colonel's Bequest...
I mean, what is the purpose that a remake actually serves? I LOVED the remakes of the first three King's Quest Games which were made with the Adventure Game Interpreter of Sierra On-Line and had this unique 80's style. I used to play adventures like Larry 1, Police Quest 1, Space Quest 1 & 2 at my Amstrad PC 1512 with a CGA 4-color monitor - those were some memories! And now, experiencing a completely retouched version of these OLD games is really amazing.
I somehow feel that the LAST game to bear resemblance to these old games was Gold Rush . The game had graphics and style similar to the first adventures of Sierra On-Line but it was way more mature than the rest and seemed - to me - like the last of its kind. Thats why I voted only for this game. Oh, I also voted for Kings Quest 8, because I feel the series DESERVES to have a point and click remake of it.
Who am I, of course, to judge someone's choices and opinions, especially when it comes to Re-making an old classic and most favourite game (Yes, in case you misunderstood, I LOVE kings quest 4) and giving it out for FREE to the world?!?!?
If AGDI Ever decides to remake King's Quest 4, I'll be one of the first to download and play the game!
It's just that if I ever was to start a "Let's remake an adventure" project, I'd choose one of the early Sierra Adventures. They give out, more than any other 3D - or pseudo 3D - adventure game this "Old, Retro" Feeling. And if I had this magic Genie who would grand me one wish for the very last remake of AGDI, I would DEFINITELY choose an old Sierra Adventure. It's this feeling I get that games like KQ4,SQ3,PQ2 etc. were already... "retouched", compared to the first Sierra Adventures.
I hope I got my point clear, my english arent as good as they used to be. Sorry for the long post . Now, back to the search for the Mandrake Root Powder...
Whats the point in re-making adventures of the , hmm, "second Sierra on-line Era" ? I'm reffering to the adventures such as Kings Quest 4, Space Quest 3, Police Quest 2, Codename:Iceman, Colonel's Bequest...
I mean, what is the purpose that a remake actually serves? I LOVED the remakes of the first three King's Quest Games which were made with the Adventure Game Interpreter of Sierra On-Line and had this unique 80's style. I used to play adventures like Larry 1, Police Quest 1, Space Quest 1 & 2 at my Amstrad PC 1512 with a CGA 4-color monitor - those were some memories! And now, experiencing a completely retouched version of these OLD games is really amazing.
I somehow feel that the LAST game to bear resemblance to these old games was Gold Rush . The game had graphics and style similar to the first adventures of Sierra On-Line but it was way more mature than the rest and seemed - to me - like the last of its kind. Thats why I voted only for this game. Oh, I also voted for Kings Quest 8, because I feel the series DESERVES to have a point and click remake of it.
Who am I, of course, to judge someone's choices and opinions, especially when it comes to Re-making an old classic and most favourite game (Yes, in case you misunderstood, I LOVE kings quest 4) and giving it out for FREE to the world?!?!?

It's just that if I ever was to start a "Let's remake an adventure" project, I'd choose one of the early Sierra Adventures. They give out, more than any other 3D - or pseudo 3D - adventure game this "Old, Retro" Feeling. And if I had this magic Genie who would grand me one wish for the very last remake of AGDI, I would DEFINITELY choose an old Sierra Adventure. It's this feeling I get that games like KQ4,SQ3,PQ2 etc. were already... "retouched", compared to the first Sierra Adventures.
I hope I got my point clear, my english arent as good as they used to be. Sorry for the long post . Now, back to the search for the Mandrake Root Powder...

-
- Royal Servant Status
- Posts: 104
- Joined: Tue Jan 08, 2008 4:21 am
- Location: LOOM
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
wow. so many KQ8 request.
Me, on the other hand, didn't really prefer the remake (or should I say "down-make") of KQ8. Yes, the art quality my be not the best, but I do enjoy it overall.
And remaking QFG5 is just way too ridiculous IMO because I really like the game since it sort-of making my dreams come true. Many friends from previous adventures, all loose-ends are answered, and finally: fighting the giant bad-ass dragon with companions too. It's way too awesome and I haven't see any game that delivers this scenario perfectly like this one. A true masterpiece. I don't see the point of de-making the "already" great and awesome game. What could be the reason, which I couldn't imagine, doing this game?
Me, on the other hand, didn't really prefer the remake (or should I say "down-make") of KQ8. Yes, the art quality my be not the best, but I do enjoy it overall.
And remaking QFG5 is just way too ridiculous IMO because I really like the game since it sort-of making my dreams come true. Many friends from previous adventures, all loose-ends are answered, and finally: fighting the giant bad-ass dragon with companions too. It's way too awesome and I haven't see any game that delivers this scenario perfectly like this one. A true masterpiece. I don't see the point of de-making the "already" great and awesome game. What could be the reason, which I couldn't imagine, doing this game?
-
- Knight Status
- Posts: 304
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 4:18 pm
- Location: The Netherlands
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
I voted:
1. Police Quest II: The Vengeance
2. Codename: Iceman
3. Laura Bow: The Colonel's Bequest
These three are among my top 10 favorite Sierra adventures for sure.
1. Police Quest II: The Vengeance
2. Codename: Iceman
3. Laura Bow: The Colonel's Bequest
These three are among my top 10 favorite Sierra adventures for sure.
-
- Knight Status
- Posts: 276
- Joined: Sun Mar 31, 2002 12:35 am
- Contact:
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
Of course, I forgot. Any three games I'd like to see remade. Well, in that case, I'll go with King's Quest 8, King's Quest 4, and The Colonel's Bequest.
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
King's Quest VII
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
1 Camelot - first graphics game I played and was blown away. Recently tried to play again and still stuck at the wild boar!
2 KQ4 - but recently replayed and got into type interface surprisingly quickly
3 Hmm - would love Colonel's Bequest and both Manhunters, difficult to choose so lets say MH NY and hope the others would follow.
Frances
2 KQ4 - but recently replayed and got into type interface surprisingly quickly
3 Hmm - would love Colonel's Bequest and both Manhunters, difficult to choose so lets say MH NY and hope the others would follow.
Frances
-
- Royal Vizier Status
- Posts: 2055
- Joined: Thu Mar 18, 2004 6:20 am
- Location: Somewhere in Ohio...
- Contact:
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
There was a lot removed from QfG5, actually. The multiplayer component, for example, which is where the unused equipment in QfG5 comes from (Magnum Opus uses the Ornate Shield and the Notched Spear while Elsa can use the (Magic) Bow which finally gives a use to all those arrows you get from defeated mercenaries). In addition, Wizard's Whirl was supposed to be in QfG5; you would have to beat Erasmus at the game to get the Whirlwind spell rather than just getting it handed to you. The was also the lack of Punny Bones, but that was supposedly due to negative fan reaction rather than a dropped element. As such, a QfG5 "de-make" might actually wind up adding quite a few enhancements.Bobbin Threadbare wrote:And remaking QFG5 is just way too ridiculous IMO because I really like the game since it sort-of making my dreams come true. Many friends from previous adventures, all loose-ends are answered, and finally: fighting the giant bad-ass dragon with companions too. It's way too awesome and I haven't see any game that delivers this scenario perfectly like this one. A true masterpiece. I don't see the point of de-making the "already" great and awesome game. What could be the reason, which I couldn't imagine, doing this game?
-
- Peasant Status
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Fri Feb 25, 2011 1:49 pm
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
My first post. I've been a silent reader of these boards for years, but I finally registered just so I could cast my vote.
I went with:
1. The Colonel's Bequest - I always thought the Laura Bow games were criminally under-appreciated. Sure, Amon Ra has some issues, but the setting was fun, and the artwork was beautiful. I'd love to see what AGDI could do with the bayou.
2. Police Quest 2 - Simply because it's my favorite in the series, and if anyone can do it justice, you guys can.
3. Conquests of Camelot - Again, this is just a game I think got overlooked because it wasn't part of a larger series. I remember finding it in a bargain bin waaaay back in the day and falling in love with it, but I was always partial to fantasy stuff like this.
It was REAL close between Camelot and KQ4. It would be cool to see AGDI polish off the whole KQ series.
That said, I would love to see some new "Sierra" games as well. Meaning, instead of a remake, an entirely new Laura Bow or QFG title. It seems like a good way for AGDI to tell their own, original story, but in an established universe with beloved characters. Not that I'm disappointed with their original IPs - Mage's Initiation sounds great - but I'd still jump for joy over a new entry into an existing series.
I went with:
1. The Colonel's Bequest - I always thought the Laura Bow games were criminally under-appreciated. Sure, Amon Ra has some issues, but the setting was fun, and the artwork was beautiful. I'd love to see what AGDI could do with the bayou.
2. Police Quest 2 - Simply because it's my favorite in the series, and if anyone can do it justice, you guys can.
3. Conquests of Camelot - Again, this is just a game I think got overlooked because it wasn't part of a larger series. I remember finding it in a bargain bin waaaay back in the day and falling in love with it, but I was always partial to fantasy stuff like this.
It was REAL close between Camelot and KQ4. It would be cool to see AGDI polish off the whole KQ series.
That said, I would love to see some new "Sierra" games as well. Meaning, instead of a remake, an entirely new Laura Bow or QFG title. It seems like a good way for AGDI to tell their own, original story, but in an established universe with beloved characters. Not that I'm disappointed with their original IPs - Mage's Initiation sounds great - but I'd still jump for joy over a new entry into an existing series.
-
- Royal Servant Status
- Posts: 104
- Joined: Tue Jan 08, 2008 4:21 am
- Location: LOOM
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
I do kinda heard those. Though this would be actually making the "complete" version, not re/de-making it.Brainiac wrote:There was a lot removed from QfG5, actually. The multiplayer component, for example, which is where the unused equipment in QfG5 comes from (Magnum Opus uses the Ornate Shield and the Notched Spear while Elsa can use the (Magic) Bow which finally gives a use to all those arrows you get from defeated mercenaries). In addition, Wizard's Whirl was supposed to be in QfG5; you would have to beat Erasmus at the game to get the Whirlwind spell rather than just getting it handed to you. The was also the lack of Punny Bones, but that was supposedly due to negative fan reaction rather than a dropped element. As such, a QfG5 "de-make" might actually wind up adding quite a few enhancements.
Btw, rather surprised MoE gathers this much. You guys must be really hate the original huh...

-
- The Master of All Things Musical
- Posts: 4031
- Joined: Tue Aug 20, 2002 8:57 pm
- Location: Manitoba, Canada
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
I don't hate MOE, but I'd really love to see Daniel re-pen the story line as a P&C adventure and embellish the plot and puzzles appropriately.
-
- The Prince of Shapeir
- Posts: 8891
- Joined: Tue May 08, 2001 4:12 am
- Location: Phobos
- Contact:
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
I think the concept behind a Quest for Glory V de-make wouldn't be to remove and change things. For example, events like the Hydra and Dragon battles could be kept intact, but the game could be given more of a classic VGA appearance and style, closer to the beautiful artwork of Quest for Glory IV. I took a look at Quest for Glory V again recently, and I was sad to see that the backgrounds are horribly compressed with what looks like some kind of JPG quality. The game was great, but it just didn't have the classic charm that a VGA point & click facelift could lend it. One thing I'd personally change would be those dancing man lock picking puzzles. Didn't like them and thought they took the player out of the mood of a tense moment.
I, too, am surprised to see the high reaction to a Mask of Eternity remake in the classic Point & Click style. It could make for a very interesting KQ game, especially if it maintained some of MOE's RPG elements...
Poor Manhunter 2: San Francisco... nobody loves it.
I, too, am surprised to see the high reaction to a Mask of Eternity remake in the classic Point & Click style. It could make for a very interesting KQ game, especially if it maintained some of MOE's RPG elements...
Poor Manhunter 2: San Francisco... nobody loves it.
-
- Royal Servant Status
- Posts: 104
- Joined: Tue Jan 08, 2008 4:21 am
- Location: LOOM
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
it's not love, it's gory. That's what Manhunter is all about. Unless MH1 has been remaked, there's no point doing the sequel. Actually, I'm more concerned about completing the trilogy, which is supposedly ManHunter: London.
Anyway, I didn't know you really care about the artwork quality that much for I'm really at awe for the whole presentation. QFG5 still one of the best games aside QFG2 for me.
Anyway, I didn't know you really care about the artwork quality that much for I'm really at awe for the whole presentation. QFG5 still one of the best games aside QFG2 for me.

Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
Why isn't TSL on that list?


-
- Defense Minister Status
- Posts: 584
- Joined: Sun Jul 27, 2008 1:22 pm
- Location: Nova Scotia, Canada
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
As much as a De-Make of 5 would be awesome, my love for the LL series lives on.
That perverted so-and-so haha.
That perverted so-and-so haha.
-
- The Prince of Shapeir
- Posts: 8891
- Joined: Tue May 08, 2001 4:12 am
- Location: Phobos
- Contact:
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
Because Lucasfan already did it:Lambonius wrote:Why isn't TSL on that list?
http://www.bigbluecup.com/yabb/index.php?topic=41402.0
-
- The Master of All Things Musical
- Posts: 4031
- Joined: Tue Aug 20, 2002 8:57 pm
- Location: Manitoba, Canada
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
That was LUCASFAN! That just made it all the more epic! lol
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
It's kinda difficult to know for sure...but this kind of thing was his schtick years ago.


-
- The Prince of Shapeir
- Posts: 8891
- Joined: Tue May 08, 2001 4:12 am
- Location: Phobos
- Contact:
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
Heh, I know, I know.That was LUCASFAN! That just made it all the more epic! lol
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
What should happen is that Activision should commission AGDI/Himalaya studios to remake KQ4 and Wizard and the Princess and then sell a King's Quest 30th Anniversary edition that works on modern computers using AGDI's remakes for like $30. I'd pay $30 for 8 great adventure games! (Well 7 great games and then a bonus remake of a game that is only questionably in the King's Quest cannon)
-
- Royal Servant Status
- Posts: 104
- Joined: Tue Jan 08, 2008 4:21 am
- Location: LOOM
Re: Future Remake: Part Deux
Remaking Wizard & the Princess would be like the making of the Hobbit for the LotR franchise. 
